All postsProducts and sourcing / THE BLOG

Compare two supplier quotes before you buy inventory

By Ashley Kays Rabbitt ·

A supplier charging $13 per unit can cost less than one charging $12. Put both quotes on the same footing before committing cash to your first order.

The smaller order can win twice

Imagine two suppliers quote the same bag in the same size, material and packaging. Supplier A asks $12 each for 100 units and $200 freight. Supplier B asks $13 each for 50 units and $25 freight. In this example the full order is paid upfront, everything arrives in sellable condition, and the remaining charges are zero.

Two illustrative first orders in US dollars
MeasureSupplier ASupplier B
Goods$1,200$650
Goods plus freight$1,400$675
Cost per sellable unit$14.00$13.50

Supplier B preserves $725 in cash. Now try a less tidy outcome. If five of B’s bags arrive unsellable and there’s no credit, its cost rises to $675 ÷ 45 = $15 per sellable bag. B still requires less cash, while A now has the lower unit cost. Which matters more for your first test?

Put each quote into the worksheet

Download the supplier comparison (CSV). Open it in Excel or Google Sheets. The first two columns reproduce the worked example. The third shows the five-unit loss.

  1. Choose one currency, delivery address and product specification. Record when the quote expires.
  2. Enter the quantity, unit price, freight and any packaging, handling, import or inspection costs you actually expect to pay. A blank supplier answer is an open question. Ask before treating it as zero.
  3. Record the number of sellable units. Divide total landed cost by that number. Record the quoted cash due upfront separately if the supplier offers terms.
  4. Change one assumption at a time. If the winner changes when freight rises slightly or two units are damaged, resolve that uncertainty before placing the order.

Send one request that suppliers can answer

Could you quote [product and specification] at [quantity] delivered to [destination], in [currency]? Please itemize goods, packaging, setup, freight and other charges. Which costs will I need to pay separately? Please include minimum order, sample price, lead time, payment milestones, damage or replacement policy and quote expiry. If you offer a smaller trial order, please quote it separately.

Decide whether a sample is worth buying

Compare a sample against the exact size, finish and packaging your customer expects. Ask how the supplier handles a defective batch and whether the sample cost carries into the first order. Document those answers alongside the math. A directory such as SaleHoo is one place to identify candidates. The supplier’s written quote and sample give you the evidence for your decision.

Before committing, check the selling side too: fees, fulfillment, returns and the price a customer will actually pay. Use the contribution margin guide for that step.

OPTIONAL PAID SUPPORT

Ecommerce Growth Coaching · $750 / month

Two working sessions per month on one growth priority, with written next steps and one agreed artifact review.

Start with a free fit conversation. A written scope and payment instructions come before paid work begins.